1: Tillie Walker (11)
2: Babe Ruth (11)
3: Gavvy Cravath (8)
4: Cy Williams (6)
5: Home Run Baker (6)
6: George Burns (6)
7: Walton Cruise (6)
8: Harry Heilmann (5)
9: Fred Luderus (5)
10: George Cutshaw (5)
11: Rogers Hornsby (5)
12: Edd Roush (5)
13: Smoky Joe Wood (5)
14: Hi Myers (4)
15: Max Flack (4)
16: Irish Meusel (4)
17: Cliff Heathcote (4)
18: Al Wickland (4)
19: George Burns (4)
20: Joe Dugan (3)
21: Dode Paskert (3)
22: Ty Cobb (3)
23: Ping Bodie (3)
24: Claude Hendrix (3)
25: Larry Doyle (3)
26: Bobby Veach (3)
27: Max Carey (3)
28: Fred Merkle (3)
29: Mike Gonzalez (3)
30: George Sisler (2)
31: Charlie Hollocher (2)
32: Les Mann (2)
33: Charlie Deal (2)
34: Ham Hyatt (2)
35: Tommy Griffith (2)
36: Bob Fisher (2)
37: Hal Chase (2)
38: Jake Daubert (2)
39: Bill McKechnie (2)
40: Wally Pipp (2)
41: Truck Hannah (2)
42: Benny Kauff (2)
43: Ed Konetchy (2)
44: Del Pratt (2)
45: Billy Southworth (2)
46: Eddie Collins (2)
47: Sherry Magee (2)
48: Doug Baird (2)
49: Red Smith (2)
50: Bob O'Farrell (1)
51: Heinie Groh (1)
52: Tom Hughes (1)
53: Walter Johnson (1)
54: Lee King (1)
55: Fred McMullin (1)
56: Bill Wagner (1)
57: Chuck Wortman (1)
58: Jim Hickman (1)
59: Marty Kavanagh (1)
60: Elmer Miller (1)
61: Casey Stengel (1)
62: Heinie Zimmerman (1)
63: Lena Blackburne (1)
64: Harry Hooper (1)
65: Bill Sherdel (1)
66: Frank Walker (1)
67: Joe Evans (1)
68: Patsy McGaffigan (1)
69: Ollie O'Mara (1)
70: Wally Rehg (1)
71: Jack Coffey (1)
72: Ray Demmitt (1)
73: Cy Perkins (1)
74: Braggo Roth (1)
75: Larry Gardner (1)
76: Austin McHenry (1)
77: Jimmy Smith (1)
78: Shano Collins (1)
79: Joe Judge (1)
80: Oscar Stanage (1)
81: Ross Youngs (1)
82: Carson Bigbee (1)
83: Dave Davenport (1)
84: Happy Felsch (1)
85: Joe Gedeon (1)
86: Walter Holke (1)
87: Greasy Neale (1)
88: Jim Thorpe (1)
89: George Whiteman (1)
90: Herman Bronkie (1)
91: Buzz Murphy (1)
92: Ivy Olson (1)
93: Howie Shanks (1)
94: Milt Stock (1)
95: Nick Altrock (1)
96: Ray Caldwell (1)
97: Shoeless Joe Jackson (1)
98: Jakie May (1)
99: Ray Chapman (1)
100: Steve O'Neill (1)
101: Frank Gilhooley (1)
102: Pete Schneider (1)
103: Babe Pinelli (1)
104: Swede Risberg (1)
105: Fred Thomas (1)
106: Mack Wheat (1)