1: Tim Jordan (12)
2: Honus Wagner (10)
3: Sam Crawford (7)
4: Red Murray (7)
5: Bill Hinchman (6)
6: Joe Tinker (6)
7: Mike Donlin (6)
8: Harry Niles (5)
9: Ed Konetchy (5)
10: Harry Davis (5)
11: Cy Seymour (5)
12: George Stone (5)
13: Tommy Leach (5)
14: Johnny Kling (4)
15: John Hummel (4)
16: Hans Lobert (4)
17: Danny Murphy (4)
18: Simon Nicholls (4)
19: Topsy Hartsel (4)
20: Harry Lumley (4)
21: Jimmy Williams (4)
22: Ty Cobb (4)
23: Doc Gessler (3)
24: Billy Maloney (3)
25: Kitty Bransfield (3)
26: Chief Wilson (3)
27: Germany Schaefer (3)
28: Bill Dahlen (3)
29: John Kane (3)
30: Ollie Pickering (2)
31: Jack Thoney (2)
32: Fred Clarke (2)
33: Art Devlin (2)
34: Frank Chance (2)
35: Mickey Doolin (2)
36: John Titus (2)
37: Roy Hartzell (2)
38: Fred Tenney (2)
39: Joe Kelley (2)
40: Jimmy Sheckard (2)
41: Jake Stahl (2)
42: Dan McGann (2)
43: Nap Lajoie (2)
44: Hobe Ferris (2)
45: Jack Hannifin (2)
46: Charlie Hickman (2)
47: Ginger Beaumont (2)
48: Doc Crandall (2)
49: Solly Hofman (2)
50: Amby McConnell (2)
51: Sherry Magee (2)
52: George Gibson (2)
53: Harry Lord (2)
54: Fred Osborn (2)
55: Claude Ritchey (2)
56: George Stovall (2)
57: Joe Birmingham (2)
58: Al Burch (2)
59: Claude Rossman (2)
60: Dick Bayless (1)
61: Danny Hoffman (1)
62: Wilbur Good (1)
63: Frank LaPorte (1)
64: Bill Bradley (1)
65: Nig Clarke (1)
66: Gavvy Cravath (1)
67: Tom Jones (1)
68: Fred Merkle (1)
69: Al Schweitzer (1)
70: Alan Storke (1)
71: Rube Waddell (1)
72: Chappy Charles (1)
73: Jack Coombs (1)
74: Pat Donahue (1)
75: Emmet Heidrick (1)
76: Del Howard (1)
77: Mike Mitchell (1)
78: Syd Smith (1)
79: Ed Abbaticchio (1)
80: Walter Blair (1)
81: Red Downs (1)
82: Bob Ganley (1)
83: Rube Oldring (1)
84: Admiral Schlei (1)
85: Bob Unglaub (1)
86: Ed Walsh (1)
87: Joe Delahanty (1)
88: Red Kleinow (1)
89: Phil Lewis (1)
90: George Mullin (1)
91: Boss Schmidt (1)
92: Tom Catterson (1)
93: Eddie Collins (1)
94: Rudy Hulswitt (1)
95: Al Shaw (1)
96: Frank Bowerman (1)
97: Josh Clarke (1)
98: Fielder Jones (1)
99: Frank Schulte (1)
100: George Browne (1)
101: Wid Conroy (1)
102: Jerry Freeman (1)
103: Frank Isbell (1)
104: Willie Keeler (1)
105: Dode Paskert (1)
106: Clyde Milan (1)
107: Harry Smith (1)
108: Heinie Wagner (1)
109: Hal Chase (1)
110: Otis Clymer (1)
111: Harry Howell (1)
112: Spike Shannon (1)
113: Gabby Street (1)
114: Roy Thomas (1)
115: Bobby Wallace (1)
116: Whitey Alpermann (1)
117: Johnny Bates (1)
118: Jack Bliss (1)
119: Jim Delahanty (1)
120: John Ganzel (1)
121: Larry McLean (1)
122: Tom Reilly (1)
123: Harry Steinfeldt (1)
124: Roger Bresnahan (1)
125: Joe Lake (1)