1: Dan Brouthers (8)
2: Charlie Bennett (7)
3: Jack Farrell (5)
4: Tom Burns (4)
5: Lew Brown (3)
6: Fred Dunlap (3)
7: Tom York (2)
8: George Bradley (2)
9: George Wood (2)
10: King Kelly (2)
11: Paul Hines (2)
12: Joe Hornung (2)
13: Hick Carpenter (2)
14: Hardy Richardson (2)
15: Harry Stovey (2)
16: Roger Connor (2)
17: Ned Hanlon (2)
18: Jack Burdock (1)
19: Buttercup Dickerson (1)
20: Cap Anson (1)
21: Silver Flint (1)
22: Lon Knight (1)
23: Candy Nelson (1)
24: Pete Hotaling (1)
25: Martin Powell (1)
26: Ned Williamson (1)
27: George Gore (1)
28: John Richmond (1)
29: Frank Hankinson (1)
30: Jack Rowe (1)
31: Bill Phillips (1)
32: Curry Foley (1)
33: Abner Dalrymple (1)
34: Sadie Houck (1)
35: John Morrill (1)
36: John Cassidy (1)
37: Emil Gross (1)
38: Jerry Denny (1)
39: Joe Quest (1)
40: Bob Ferguson (1)
41: Orator Shafer (1)