Awarded annually to one pitcher in the American League and one in the National League
2017: Max Scherzer (NL)
2017: Corey Kluber (AL)
2016: Max Scherzer (NL)
2016: Rick Porcello (AL)
2015: Jake Arrieta (NL)
2015: Dallas Keuchel (AL)
2014: Clayton Kershaw (NL)
2014: Corey Kluber (AL)
2013: Clayton Kershaw (NL)
2013: Max Scherzer (AL)
2012: R. A. Dickey (NL)
2012: David Price (AL)
2011: Clayton Kershaw (NL)
2011: Justin Verlander (AL)
2010: Roy Halladay (NL)
2010: Felix Hernandez (AL)
2009: Tim Lincecum (NL)
2009: Zack Greinke (AL)
2008: Tim Lincecum (NL)
2008: Cliff Lee (AL)
2007: Jake Peavy (NL)
2007: CC Sabathia (AL)
2006: Brandon Webb (NL)
2006: Johan Santana (AL)
2005: Chris Carpenter (NL)
2005: Bartolo Colon (AL)
2004: Roger Clemens (NL)
2004: Johan Santana (AL)
2003: Eric Gagne (NL)
2003: Roy Halladay (AL)
2002: Randy Johnson (NL)
2002: Barry Zito (AL)
2001: Randy Johnson (NL)
2001: Roger Clemens (AL)
2000: Randy Johnson (NL)
2000: Pedro Martinez (AL)
1999: Randy Johnson (NL)
1999: Pedro Martinez (AL)
1998: Tom Glavine (NL)
1998: Roger Clemens (AL)
1997: Pedro Martinez (NL)
1997: Roger Clemens (AL)
1996: John Smoltz (NL)
1996: Pat Hentgen (AL)
1995: Greg Maddux (NL)
1995: Randy Johnson (AL)
1994: Greg Maddux (NL)
1994: David Cone (AL)
1993: Greg Maddux (NL)
1993: Jack McDowell (AL)
1992: Greg Maddux (NL)
1992: Dennis Eckersley (AL)
1991: Tom Glavine (NL)
1991: Roger Clemens (AL)
1990: Doug Drabek (NL)
1990: Bob Welch (AL)
1989: Mark Davis (NL)
1989: Bret Saberhagen (AL)
1988: Orel Hershiser (NL)
1988: Frank Viola (AL)
1987: Steve Bedrosian (NL)
1987: Roger Clemens (AL)
1986: Mike Scott (NL)
1986: Roger Clemens (AL)
1985: Dwight Gooden (NL)
1985: Bret Saberhagen (AL)
1984: Rick Sutcliffe (NL)
1984: Willie Hernandez (AL)
1983: John Denny (NL)
1983: LaMarr Hoyt (AL)
1982: Steve Carlton (NL)
1982: Pete Vuckovich (AL)
1981: Fernando Valenzuela (NL)
1981: Rollie Fingers (AL)
1980: Steve Carlton (NL)
1980: Steve Stone (AL)
1979: Bruce Sutter (NL)
1979: Mike Flanagan (AL)
1978: Gaylord Perry (NL)
1978: Ron Guidry (AL)
1977: Steve Carlton (NL)
1977: Sparky Lyle (AL)
1976: Randy Jones (NL)
1976: Jim Palmer (AL)
1975: Tom Seaver (NL)
1975: Jim Palmer (AL)
1974: Mike Marshall (NL)
1974: Catfish Hunter (AL)
1973: Tom Seaver (NL)
1973: Jim Palmer (AL)
1972: Steve Carlton (NL)
1972: Gaylord Perry (AL)
1971: Fergie Jenkins (NL)
1971: Vida Blue (AL)
1970: Bob Gibson (NL)
1970: Jim Perry (AL)
1969: Tom Seaver (NL)
1969: Denny McLain (AL)
1969: Mike Cuellar (AL)
1968: Bob Gibson (NL)
1968: Denny McLain (AL)
1967: Mike McCormick (NL)
1967: Jim Lonborg (AL)
1966: Sandy Koufax (ML)
1965: Sandy Koufax (ML)
1964: Dean Chance (ML)
1963: Sandy Koufax (ML)
1962: Don Drysdale (ML)
1961: Whitey Ford (ML)
1960: Vern Law (ML)
1959: Early Wynn (ML)
1958: Bob Turley (ML)
1957: Warren Spahn (ML)
1956: Don Newcombe (ML)