1: Oscar Walker (7)
2: George Wood (7)
3: Dan Brouthers (6)
4: Mike Muldoon (6)
5: Pete Browning (5)
6: Harry Stovey (5)
7: Jim Whitney (5)
8: Ned Hanlon (5)
9: Charlie Bennett (5)
10: Paul Hines (4)
11: Ed Swartwood (4)
12: Roger Connor (4)
13: Silver Flint (4)
14: Bill Phillips (4)
15: Sam Wise (4)
16: Jack Glasscock (4)
17: Jackie Hayes (4)
18: Jack O'Brien (3)
19: Ned Williamson (3)
20: Guy Hecker (3)
21: George Gore (3)
22: Curry Foley (3)
23: Billy Taylor (3)
24: Orator Shafer (3)
25: Chappy Lane (3)
26: Frank Mountain (2)
27: Jerry Denny (2)
28: Buck Ewing (2)
29: Jack Farrell (2)
30: John Morrill (2)
31: Ezra Sutton (2)
32: Patrick Gillespie (2)
33: Hardy Richardson (2)
34: Blondie Purcell (2)
35: Jim O'Rourke (2)
36: Lee Richmond (2)
37: George Strief (2)
38: Jack Gleason (2)
39: Jim McCormick (2)
40: Mike Mansell (2)
41: Hick Carpenter (1)
42: Jack Rowe (1)
43: Tom Brown (1)
44: Harry Jacoby (1)
45: Bob Casey (1)
46: Denny Driscoll (1)
47: Davy Force (1)
48: Tim Keefe (1)
49: Bid McPhee (1)
50: John Ward (1)
51: Bill Gleason (1)
52: Joe Hornung (1)
53: Jimmy Say (1)
54: Pop Snyder (1)
55: Joe Battin (1)
56: Mickey Welch (1)
57: Tom York (1)
58: Charlie Householder (1)
59: John Reccius (1)
60: Doc Bushong (1)
61: Dave Rowe (1)
62: Deacon White (1)
63: Charlie Comiskey (1)
64: Hugh Nicol (1)
65: Abner Dalrymple (1)
66: Ed Rowen (1)
67: Cap Anson (1)
68: Larry Corcoran (1)
69: Frank McLaughlin (1)
70: George Creamer (1)
71: Jim Keenan (1)
72: Old Hoss Radbourn (1)
73: Lou Say (1)
74: Joe Sommer (1)
75: King Kelly (1)
76: Fred Pfeffer (1)
77: Chief Roseman (1)
78: Harry Wheeler (1)
79: Joe Farrell (1)
80: Jack Leary (1)
81: Nick Scharf (1)