1: Dan Brouthers (11)
2: Hardy Richardson (11)
3: Cap Anson (10)
4: Jerry Denny (9)
5: Paul Hines (9)
6: Alex McKinnon (8)
7: Bid McPhee (8)
8: Sam Thompson (8)
9: John Morrill (7)
10: Fred Pfeffer (7)
11: Harry Stovey (7)
12: Roger Connor (7)
13: Dave Orr (7)
14: Fred Dunlap (7)
15: Jack Rowe (6)
16: Frank Fennelly (6)
17: John Reilly (6)
18: Ed Williamson (6)
19: George Gore (6)
20: Charley Jones (6)
21: James Roseman (5)
22: John Milligan (5)
23: John Corkhill (5)
24: Fred Carroll (5)
25: Sid Farrar (5)
26: Ed Daily (4)
27: King Kelly (4)
28: Sam Wise (4)
29: Buck Ewing (4)
30: George Wood (4)
31: Bob Caruthers (4)
32: John Kerins (4)
33: Guy Hecker (4)
34: Jimmy Ryan (4)
35: Jocko Flynn (4)
36: Ned Hanlon (4)
37: Charlie Bennett (4)
38: Mox McQuery (4)
39: Al Myers (4)
40: Tom Burns (3)
41: Jack Glasscock (3)
42: Ed Swartwood (3)
43: Mert Hackett (3)
44: Jim Keenan (3)
45: Tip O'Neill (3)
46: Lou Sylvester (3)
47: Kid Baldwin (3)
48: Abner Dalrymple (3)
49: Jim Fogarty (3)
50: William Robinson (3)
51: Ezra Sutton (3)
52: Jimmy Peoples (3)
53: Charlie Comiskey (3)
54: Dave Foutz (3)
55: Jackie Hayes (3)
56: Dave Rowe (3)
57: Joe Werrick (3)
58: Dude Esterbrook (3)
59: John Clarkson (3)
60: Tom Poorman (3)
61: Chicken Wolf (3)
62: Jimmy Knowles (3)
63: Pete Conway (3)
64: Lou Bierbauer (2)
65: Charley Bassett (2)
66: Charlie Ferguson (2)
67: Jim McTamany (2)
68: Fred Mann (2)
69: Deacon McGuire (2)
70: Pete Browning (2)
71: Frank Hankinson (2)
72: Cliff Carroll (2)
73: Joe Mulvey (2)
74: Jim McCormick (2)
75: John Ward (2)
76: Jack Farrell (2)
77: Milt Scott (2)
78: Adonis Terry (2)
79: Jim Whitney (2)
80: Mike Dorgan (2)
81: Jack McGeachey (2)
82: Germany Smith (2)
83: Curt Welch (2)
84: Henry Larkin (2)
85: Pop Smith (2)
86: Charlie Bastian (2)
87: Fred Lewis (2)
88: John Meister (2)
89: Hick Carpenter (2)
90: Old Hoss Radbourn (2)
91: Joe Hornung (2)
92: George Miller (2)
93: Ed Andrews (2)
94: Ernie Burch (2)
95: Chippy McGarr (2)
96: Emmett Seery (2)
97: Jumbo McGinnis (1)
98: Arlie Latham (1)
99: Al Mays (1)
100: Billy Nash (1)