1: Hugh Duffy (11)
2: George Davis (10)
3: Nap Lajoie (9)
4: Mike Grady (8)
5: Jake Beckley (8)
6: General Stafford (7)
7: Jimmy Collins (6)
8: Mike Smith (6)
9: Klondike Douglass (6)
10: Fred Clarke (6)
11: Jack Clements (6)
12: Bill Dahlen (6)
13: Mike Tiernan (5)
14: Bobby Lowe (5)
15: Perry Werden (5)
16: Bill Everitt (5)
17: Kip Selbach (5)
18: Ed Delahanty (5)
19: Bill Lange (5)
20: Tom McCreery (5)
21: Jimmy Ryan (5)
22: Tommy Tucker (5)
23: George Decker (5)
24: Tom Brown (5)
25: Joe Kelley (5)
26: Frank Shugart (5)
27: Candy LaChance (4)
28: John Anderson (4)
29: Monte Cross (4)
30: Jake Stenzel (4)
31: Duff Cooley (4)
32: Chick Stahl (4)
33: Deacon McGuire (4)
34: Dusty Miller (4)
35: Billy Shindle (4)
36: Bobby Wallace (4)
37: Jake Gettman (3)
38: Zeke Wrigley (3)
39: Jimmy Sheckard (3)
40: Gene DeMontreville (3)
41: Charlie Abbey (3)
42: Tommy Corcoran (3)
43: Herman Long (3)
44: Lave Cross (3)
45: Jimmy Callahan (3)
46: Jim Connor (3)
47: Billy Hamilton (3)
48: John O'Brien (3)
49: Cap Anson (3)
50: George Van Haltren (3)
51: Dick Harley (3)
52: Chief Sockalexis (3)
53: Bill Joyce (3)
54: Kid Nance (3)
55: Jesse Hoffmeister (3)
56: Kid Nichols (3)
57: Hughie Jennings (2)
58: Harry Davis (2)
59: Jack Doyle (2)
60: Tuck Turner (2)
61: Jim Canavan (2)
62: Dummy Hoy (2)
63: Jack Boyle (2)
64: Bill Hart (2)
65: Jack Rothfuss (2)
66: Billy Clingman (2)
67: Ed McFarland (2)
68: Honus Wagner (2)
69: Charlie Dexter (2)
70: Bones Ely (2)
71: Marty Bergen (2)
72: Buster Burrell (2)
73: Chick Fraser (2)
74: Bug Holliday (2)
75: Heinie Reitz (2)
76: Jack Warner (2)
77: Steve Brodie (2)
78: George Yeager (2)
79: Ed McKean (2)
80: Bert Cunningham (2)
81: Dan Lally (2)
82: Barry McCormick (2)
83: Ollie Pickering (2)
84: Cy Seymour (2)
85: Jack Stivetts (2)
86: Denny Lyons (2)
87: Jack O'Connor (2)
88: Jim Rogers (2)
89: Jack Fifield (2)
90: Mike Griffin (2)
91: Fred Hartman (2)
92: Dick Padden (2)
93: Jesse Burkett (2)
94: Charlie Reilly (2)
95: Bob Allen (1)
96: Ducky Holmes (1)
97: Frank Killen (1)
98: Red Donahue (1)
99: Kid Gleason (1)
100: Harry Blake (1)
101: Roger Connor (1)
102: Jim Gardner (1)
103: Heinie Smith (1)
104: Walt Wilmot (1)
105: Charlie Hickman (1)
106: Phil Geier (1)
107: Fred Klobedanz (1)
108: Al Orth (1)
109: Eddie Burke (1)
110: Bill Hoffer (1)
111: Joe Quinn (1)
112: Boileryard Clarke (1)
113: Charlie Hastings (1)
114: Bill Merritt (1)
115: Brickyard Kennedy (1)
116: Aleck Smith (1)
117: Heinie Peitz (1)
118: Pop Schriver (1)
119: Jack Taylor (1)
120: Willie Clark (1)
121: Fielder Jones (1)
122: Frank Bowerman (1)
123: Malachi Kittridge (1)
124: Bid McPhee (1)
125: Fred Tenney (1)
126: Bill Wilson (1)
127: Cupid Childs (1)