1: Gavvy Cravath (19)
2: Fred Luderus (18)
3: Vic Saier (14)
4: Home Run Baker (12)
5: Sherry Magee (11)
6: Chief Wilson (10)
7: Heinie Zimmerman (9)
8: Sam Crawford (9)
9: Beals Becker (9)
10: Frank Schulte (9)
11: Ping Bodie (8)
12: Ed Konetchy (8)
13: Zack Wheat (7)
14: Shoeless Joe Jackson (7)
15: Dots Miller (7)
16: Casey Stengel (7)
17: Hans Lobert (7)
18: George Cutshaw (7)
19: Tommy Leach (6)
20: Red Smith (6)
21: Johnny Bates (6)
22: Bris Lord (6)
23: Gus Williams (5)
24: John Titus (5)
25: Max Carey (5)
26: Danny Moeller (5)
27: Joe Connolly (5)
28: Mike Mitchell (5)
29: Tillie Shafer (5)
30: Larry Doyle (5)
31: Rube Oldring (5)
32: Art Fletcher (4)
33: Buck Weaver (4)
34: Bob Fisher (4)
35: Ham Hyatt (4)
36: Stuffy McInnis (4)
37: Cy Williams (4)
38: Dode Paskert (4)
39: John Dodge (4)
40: Harry Hooper (4)
41: Ty Cobb (4)
42: Jack Barry (3)
43: Josh Devore (3)
44: Clyde Milan (3)
45: Eddie Collins (3)
46: Bill Rariden (3)
47: Ray Chapman (3)
48: Les Mann (3)
49: Rafael Almeida (3)
50: Tris Speaker (3)
51: Dick Hoblitzell (3)
52: Honus Wagner (3)
53: Buck Herzog (3)
54: Fred Merkle (3)
55: Wally Schang (3)
56: Fred Snodgrass (3)
57: Hal Janvrin (3)
58: Heinie Groh (3)
59: Chief Meyers (3)
60: Johnny Evers (3)
61: Jack Graney (3)
62: Eddie Ainsmith (2)
63: Heinie Wagner (2)
64: Jeff Sweeney (2)
65: Jean Dubuc (2)
66: George Burns (2)
67: Jimmy Austin (2)
68: Otto Hess (2)
69: Art Phelan (2)
70: Harry Wolter (2)
71: Clyde Engle (2)
72: Del Pratt (2)
73: Jim Viox (2)
74: Hal Chase (2)
75: Pete Compton (2)
76: Hap Myers (2)
77: Jake Daubert (2)
78: Johnny Johnston (2)
79: Slim Sallee (2)
80: Sam Agnew (2)
81: Joe Berger (2)
82: Jimmy Archer (2)
83: John Hummel (2)
84: Ivey Wingo (2)
85: Rabbit Maranville (2)
86: Red Murray (2)
87: Red Corriden (2)
88: Doc Johnston (2)
89: Otto Knabe (2)
90: Lee Magee (2)
91: Ossie Vitt (2)
92: Johnny Beall (2)
93: Bobby Byrne (2)
94: Del Gainer (2)
95: Walter Johnson (2)
96: Tom Seaton (1)
97: Marty Berghammer (1)
98: Jim Thorpe (1)
99: Mike Simon (1)
100: Boardwalk Brown (1)
101: Steve Yerkes (1)
102: Chick Gandil (1)
103: Ray Schalk (1)
104: Tommy Clarke (1)
105: Eddie Foster (1)
106: Jack Lapp (1)
107: Red McKee (1)
108: Reb Russell (1)
109: Shano Collins (1)
110: Eddie Murphy (1)
111: Howie Shanks (1)
112: Donie Bush (1)
113: Jack Fournier (1)
114: Chief Johnson (1)
115: Claud Derrick (1)
116: Nap Lajoie (1)
117: Al Bridwell (1)
118: Ed Willett (1)
119: Mickey Doolin (1)
120: Steve Evans (1)
121: George McBride (1)
122: Ward Miller (1)
123: Jim Scott (1)
124: Pinch Thomas (1)
125: Jack Calvo (1)
126: Harry Lord (1)
127: Burt Shotton (1)
128: John Henry (1)
129: Bob Bescher (1)
130: Joe Tinker (1)
131: Guy Zinn (1)
132: Enos Kirkpatrick (1)
133: Harry Williams (1)
134: Ray Collins (1)
135: Frank Allen (1)
136: George Stovall (1)
137: Roger Bresnahan (1)
138: Wilbur Good (1)
139: Roger Peckinpaugh (1)
140: Drummond Brown (1)
141: Birdie Cree (1)
142: William Fischer (1)
143: Tommy Griffith (1)
144: Benny Meyer (1)
145: Paddy Baumann (1)
146: Claude Hendrix (1)
147: Rip Williams (1)
148: Joe Lake (1)
149: Butch Schmidt (1)
150: Bunny Brief (1)